SIGI Director Cynthia S Nicholson Sells $364K of Stock

Cynthia S Nicholson, a Director at Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI), sold 3,691 shares on October 26, 2026, for about $364,342. The sale was reported in a Form 4 filing with the SEC. Nicholson's sale reduced her stake by 17.45%, leaving her with approximately 17,463 shares.

SIGI Selective Insurance Group, Inc.

$98.79 ▲ +20.01% year to date

1M 3M YTD

Daily close · Oct 26, 2026

Inside Cynthia S Nicholson's Trade

Nicholson sold her shares at a price of $98.71 each. This transaction was not part of a planned sale. Her current holdings now stand at 17,463 shares, reflecting a significant decrease in her ownership.

Other Institutional Activity in Selective Insurance

AQR Capital Management, LLC reduced its holdings by 591,707 shares, ending with 3,345,130 shares worth about $330.5 million. American Century Companies Inc. increased its stake by 961,717 shares, totaling 2,228,969 shares valued at approximately $220.2 million. First Trust Advisors LP added 228,283 shares, bringing its total to 1,610,141 shares, worth about $159.1 million.

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. Stock Up 7.0%

The stock recently traded around $98.13, which is above its 50-day moving average of $88.92, indicating strong price momentum. However, it remains below its 52-week high of $101.25, suggesting it has not yet reached its peak for the year. The recent trading level is also about 2.3% below the mean price target of $100.43 set by analysts.

Recent Earnings

Selective Insurance reported trailing twelve-month revenue of about $5.44 billion with a net margin of 9.4%. The company has a return on equity (ROE) of 14.7%. Its next earnings report is expected on January 28, 2027.

Insider Buying and Selling at Selective Insurance Group, Inc.

In addition to Nicholson's sale, other insiders have made trades earlier this year. Lisa Rojas Bacus, a Director, bought 600 shares at an average price of $84.81 on February 2, 2026. Anthony D. Harnett, an Officer, sold 1,064 shares at $87.32 on February 17, 2026, and also sold 955 shares at $85.31 on February 2, 2026. Michael H Lanza, General Counsel, sold 17,100 shares at $94.04 on July 28, 2026.

Analysts Set New Price Targets

On July 15, 2026, Piper Sandler maintained a "Neutral" rating with a price target of $103.00, up from a prior target of $93.00. RBC Capital maintained an "Outperform" rating with a target of $115.00, increased from $110.00 on July 27, 2026. BMO Capital downgraded its rating to "Market Perform" with a target of $97.00 on July 28, 2026. The consensus recommendation for Selective Insurance is to hold, with a mean price target of $100.43 based on seven analyst opinions.

About Selective Insurance Group, Inc.

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. provides a range of insurance products and services in the United States, operating through various segments including commercial and personal lines. With a workforce of around 2,800 employees, the company is headquartered in Branchville, New Jersey.

Bottom Line

Cynthia S Nicholson's recent sale is part of the ongoing activity among insiders at Selective Insurance. Investors should keep an eye on the upcoming earnings report on January 28, 2027, for further insights into the company's performance and any potential changes in insider trading patterns.